More fabulous sleuthing to report from Jon in New York. Public tax records revealed the first picture from 1999. The sign is labeled "Murphy Bros. Moving & Storage":

According to the tax records as researched by Jon, the building was originally constructed in 1906 and expanded in three stages during the early 1900's. The K-F Dealer List shows the building in use as a Kaiser-Frazer dealer circa 1947 and as a Willys dealership circa 1954. The intermediate years are not documented, but the property was sold to the moving company by a local church, possibly having been donated. In May 2000, the property changed hands again and was totally renovated to become the Golden Oldies Antique Store, as seen below in a picture taken Oct 7, 2003. There is presently no content at their website.

In a dispatch from Small World Department, Jon reports having been in this building while it was still in use as a warehouse, unaware it had formerly been a Willys dealership.